Home Page

The Private Reserve
Ideal Cut Diamonds
In-Stock & Available:
Diamond Inventory


Ideal Cut Classifications
AGS Ideal 0 Cut
AGS-000/Triple 0 defined

Eighternity Diamonds
GIA Excellent / Ideal
Hearts & Arrows Ideals
Just Plain "Ideal"
The Ideal Differences

Fancy Shape Desc.
Asscher Cut Diamonds
Cushion Cut Diamonds
Princess Cut Diamonds

Private Reserve Terms:
Glossary of Terms
Inventory Introduction

Engagement Rings:
Overview of Styles
Tiffany Solitaires

Gold Solitaires
Platinum Solitaires

Knife Edge Solitaires

Cathedral Solitaires
Comfort Fit Solitaires
Half Round Bands

3 Stone Rings (DeBeers)

3 Stone Rings (Fancy)


Designer Collection:
Designs by Tacori
Designs by D. Vatche
Designs by Viachi

Diamond Grading
The Expanded 4Cs

1. Cut = Light Return
2. Color
3. Clarity
4. Carat Weight

Clarity Characteristics
Degrees of Magnification
Diamond Grading Tools
Evaluating A Diamond
Fast Track to Brilliance

FireScope™
Fluorescence

Grading for Real People
Holloway Cut Advisor
Polish
Proportions

Proportions Analysis
Sarin DiaMension
Symmetry

SymmetriScope™
The 60/60 Farce
Tolkowsky Range

Buyer Beware!
Chipped Diamonds

"Empty House Listers"

Re-Cut Diamonds
Secret Stuff
Treated Diamonds

When is "Ideal" not?

Diamond Price Tools
Paid Report Access

A word about pricing...
What is the "Rap Trap"?
What is Ho-Ho-Wholesale

What is a Site Sale?

Independent Laboratories
The GIA vs. the AGS

Important Stuff
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
FAQ's or Fiction
Find an Appraiser
Kimberly Diamond Act
Ordering Information
Platinum Tips & Care
Privacy Policy
Ring Size Conversion
Shipping Information
Terms & Conditions
Time Zone 101

Trade-in Policy
What Do I Do Next?

Who Are These Nuts?
About Us
Ask A Fellow Netite
Contact Us
General Information

The Benefits of NiceIce
N.Y.D. Magazine says...
Services Offered

Visit Our Store!

Investigate Us
Jewelers Vigilance (JVC)
The Public Eye
Epinions.com

Interesting Stuff
Canadian Diamonds
Diavik Mine Canada
$295M DeBeers Settlement
Blood Diamond Movie
Sierra Leone Diamonds

The Legal Stuff
Copyright Notice

Terms & Conditions

Trade Affiliations:


Jewelers Vigilance


Jewelers of America


Manufacturing Jewelers
& Suppliers of America

StopBloodDiamonds.org Registered Jeweler

Friends, Competitors
& Shopping Favorites!

Exchange Links w/Us!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

*

*

 

The "Rap Trap"

a.k.a. the "All Diamonds 10% Under New York Wholesale Game"

The Rapaport Diamond Report™ and The Diamond Price Report™ are trade periodicals intended to be a market analysis and indicators of the current HIGH CASH ASKING PRICES of the New York Diamond Market.   Both of these publications base their estimations on an average of the current wholesale asking prices for GIA Certified Diamonds based on their shape, size, color, and clarity. These reports do NOT automatically factor in price increases for better proportions and finish or decreases in price for circumstances such as chips, scratches, poor proportions / cut, etc. but do suggest them.

This is a page from our original site, please click here to visit our current site!

Before somebody gets there feathers ruffled unnecessarily, understand that both The Rapaport Diamond Report™ and The Diamond Price Report™ are both fine publications, that when used properly are an important asset to the diamond industry.  The problem lies not with the publications, but rather with disreputable jewelers who misuse them to defraud the public.

Eventually you're going to run into a jeweler who will lay a "Rap" sheet out in front of you and say something like "You seem like a nice guy... because I like you, I'm going to sell you this diamond for 10% under Rap."  Some jewelers are even so bold as to advertise on radio, television, and the web, that all of their diamonds are priced below Rap or New York Wholesale.

The unfortunate reality is that most stores who claim to sell "at or below Rap" or "10% Under New York Wholesale" are simply misrepresenting the quality of what they are selling or selling uncertified diamonds 10% under the market asking price for certified diamonds. Keep in mind that certified diamonds always cost more than uncertified diamonds and that their grading is more reliable.

Realize that not all jewelers attempt to deceive the public by representing uncertified diamonds 10% under the recommended market price for certified diamonds.  One retailer we know advertises "GIA and EGL Certified Diamonds 10% under New York Wholesale".  Now we have to wonder, how can a retailer sell his inventory for 10% below his wholesale cost and still afford to pay his $12,000 a month lease payment and other overhead expenses?  Don't strain your brain, the answer is quite simple. Subtle differences in the quality of a diamond's cut and it's proportions can have dramatic effects on it's cost. Knowing this, you might realize what's really happening. For example, let's carefully examine two diamonds from our May 3, 1997 inventory list:

#TR31L64101 / RBCD / 1.01 / SI-1 / F / GIA CERT / $6,153.00
#TR31UD101 / RBCD / 1.01 / SI-1 / G / EGL CERT / $4,404.00

Now your brain might be asking "What's going on?" After all, these two diamonds appear to be the same with the exception of one color grade, who certified them, and $1,749.00

Naturally, all things appearing to be comparable, you're going to purchase the EGL Certified 1.01 SI-1 G because it's a deal... Heck, it's $1,749.00 cheaper than the 1.01 GIA Certified diamond from another dealer! And that's what some retailers and diamond dealers are counting on. You're naiveté.  Let's take a closer look at these diamonds with the help of the diamond grading reports.

Let's begin with the understanding that GIA and AGS graded diamonds frequently trade for as much as 10% more than diamonds graded by other laboratories because they are considered to be stronger, more accurate paper.

Reference #: TR31L64101
Price: $6,153.00
Certified By: GIA Gem Trade Laboratories
Weight: 1.01
Shape: Round Brilliant Cut
Clarity: SI-1
Color: F
Measurements: 6.49-6.55 X 3.92 mm
Depth: 60.1%
Table: 63%
Crown Angle: not provided GIA reports.
Pavilion Depth: not provided on GIA reports.
Girdle: Thin to Medium, Faceted.
Culet: None
Polish: Very Good
Symmetry: Very Good
Fluorescence: None
Comments: None

Price: $4,404.00
Certified By: European Gemological Laboratories (EGL)
Weight: 1.01
Shape: Round Brilliant Cut
Clarity: SI-1
Color: G
Measurements: 6.49-6.57 X 3.79 mm
Depth: 58%
Table: 67%
Crown: 11%
Pavilion: 43%
Girdle: Medium, Faceted.
Culet: None
Polish: GOOD
Symmetry: GOOD
Fluorescence: Moderate Blue
Comments: None

Now that we can see the details of the diamond grading reports, we can see that the EGL graded diamond does not have as nice a cut (GOOD instead of VERY GOOD) and has Moderate Blue Fluorescence where the GIA graded diamond has none. These things affect the brilliance of the diamond and the price you pay for it. The GIA Certified diamond costs more because it's of nicer make and does not have fluorescence.

Beware of "Deals" from jewelers and diamond dealers selling "at or below Rap" because they are often selling inferior goods at a fair market price and deceiving you into thinking you're paying wholesale for them by showing you industry publications that reflect recommended wholesale prices for GIA Certified round brilliant cut diamonds cut within the ideal range with no exceptions, such as fluorescence.  As with the example of the two 1.01 carat diamonds listed above, it just looks like the jeweler is doing you a favor...

Understand that each publication clearly states that prices for finer makes and fancy shapes will command higher prices.  Likewise, diamonds with poor cut and proportions cost less than better cut goods.  These reports are based on an average or "ideal range" for cut and proportions.  The reality is that they can be quite confusing to a person who has not been in the diamond industry for an extensive period of time.

We prefer to keep diamond buying simple, straightforward, and enjoyable.  We only sell round brilliant ideal cut diamonds graded by the AGS and GIA Laboratories.  We price each diamond individually based upon it's unique characteristics, thereby assuring you of the fairest price possible.  And the diamond grading reports for the diamonds that we sell are always available for your inspection upon request.  To review our on-line inventory of available diamonds, please visit The Private Reserve


May we help you find the diamond of your dreams?
Send us an email diamonds@niceice.com and tell us what you are looking for.
Or give us a call at 206.319.8152 or Toll Free 877.844.5443

Copyright © 1996 - 2009 Nice Ice, Inc.

AGS® is a registered trademark of the American Gem Society (702) 255-6500
GIA® is a registered trademark of the Gemological Institute of America (760) 603-4000